Beet sugar more sustainable than cane sugar

The production of Dutch beet sugar produces considerably less CO2 and fine particles than the production of cane sugar. Beet sugar also requires far less land and consumes significantly less water. These are the findings of a recent study carried out by the leading international consultancy, Blonk Consultants. The study has been peer reviewed by three independent organisations; SGS Search, DSM and Milieu Centraal.

Manufacturers who process sugar as an ingredient and consumers who eat sugar can do so more sustainably if they use Dutch beet sugar instead of cane sugar. Suiker Unie commissioned a study to determine as objectively as possible how beet sugar scored against cane sugar on relevant aspects of life cycle assessment (LCA). Blonk Consultants studied the impact on climate change, fine particle emissions, land use and water consumption of Dutch beet sugar in comparison with Brazilian and Indian cane sugar. It also took the impact of electricity production as a by-product of cane sugar into account and the consequences of pre-harvest burning to make the sugar cane harvest less labour intensive.

The main conclusions are:

  • The impact of Brazilian cane sugar on the climate is four times as high as that of Dutch beet sugar. The impact of Indian cane sugar is 37% higher than that of beet sugar.
  • Beet sugar production produces less than half the fine particles that Brazilian cane sugar production produces and just 38% of that of Indian cane sugar (expressed as fine particles in weight per kilogram of sugar produced).
  • It takes 50% more land to produce cane sugar in Brazil than it does to produce beet sugar. In India, nearly twice as much land is needed. Land use is expressed as the square metres needed to produce a kilogram of sugar
  • Little water is needed to produce sugar in the Netherlands and Brazil, two litres per kg sugar for beet sugar and 40 litres for Brazilian cane sugar. Indian cane sugar, by contrast, is extremely thirsty, needing more than 1,000 litres of water to produce a kilogram of sugar. The water is used to irrigate the sugar cane crop.

Would you like more detailed information about this LCA report?

Download the leaflet

  • Click here for the complete article
  • Or contact Bertram de Crom, Manager Environmental Affairs | +31 165 525 095

Share this message

Other articles

25 March 2020

Coronavirus: health and safety first

Cosun and Suiker Unie have set up a crisis team to deal with the effects of the corona crisis and keep their primary processes running. The overriding goal is to provide maximum protection to our staff,...
18 March 2020

Cosun Solar Park Puttershoek: 20 megawatts of sustainable energy

The contracts have been signed. Cosun Solar Park Puttershoek will be built this year. Following a call for tenders, the initiator and client, Suiker Unie, selected KiesZon to build the gigantic solar park....
12 February 2020

Suiker Unie Roosendaal: Excellence Award for Consistent TPM

Suiker Unie’s sugar specialities factory in Roosendaal has won the Excellence Award for Consistent TPM. After coming through the final audit by two Japanese auditors, the facility received the good...
13 January 2020

Sustainable Industry Challenge 2020: Suiker Unie selects Bioextrax as winner with the best innovation

Suiker Unie has selected Bioextrax as the winner of its challenge in the green chemical theme of the Sustainable Industry Challenge 2020. This global competition was held by Economic Board Groningen to...
27 November 2019

Beet growers were awarded the highest SAI sustainability level: FSA Gold

All Suiker Unie’s sugar beet growers have been awarded FSA Gold level. The Sustainable Agricultural Initiative platform supports sustainable farming initiatives and assesses the sustainability of...
05 November 2019

Major international challenge for green solutions in the chemical and energy sectors

In collaboration with its partners in the north of the Netherlands, Economic Board Groningen is organising an international pitch event for innovative scale-ups in the green chemical, recycling and green...
11 October 2019

Suiker Unie to produce protein from plant leaves

Suiker Unie officially took its Green Protein Demo Plant into operation on 10 October and started producing protein from sugar beet foliage. The production process is a unique, pioneering method that Suiker...
11 October 2019

Suiker Unie wins 2019 FNLI award

Suiker Unie won the 2019 FNLI award on 10 October. The Dutch Food Industry Federation (FNLI) introduced the award this year for people or teams that go to extraordinary lengths to raise innovative initiatives...
06 September 2019

Early but staggered start to the beet campaign

The sugar beet campaign will have a staggered start this year. The sugar factories will start production on 6 September in Dinteloord and on 10 September in Anklam and Groningen. Logistically, a staggered...
02 September 2019

Suiker Unie awarded EcoVadis gold rating for fifth year in succession

EcoVadis has again awarded Suiker Unie a gold rating. We are extremely proud that our commitment to sustainability has been recognised for the fifth year in succession and crowned with a gold rating for...
18 April 2019

Furthering sustainability together with Green Circles

A beautiful location and sunny day provided a perfect start for the ‘Green Circles’ sugar beet circular economy. On 18 April 2019, Suiker Unie, the province of North Brabant, and Naturalis...
14 February 2019

New bulk trucks running entirely on Suiker Unie’s own green gas

Technical advances recently made it possible to have gas-fuelled trucks transport train weights of up to 50 tonnes. The 410 hp tractor units will make Suiker Unie’s bulk transport operations even...
22 January 2019

First consumer products launched with Betafib®

‘Royal COSUN Biobased Products’, part of Suiker Unie, introduced 100% bio-based rheology modifier, developed during PULP2VALUE demonstration project, for various consumer applications such...
06 July 2018

Unveiling of the world’s first completely circular car

On Friday 6 July, Noah, the world's first completely circular car, was unveiled at the Cosun Innovation Centre in Dinteloord. The two-seater car, the chassis of which is largely made of sugar and the...